Везде
ONCE MORE ON RESPONSA OF ROMAN JURISTS AND DISPUTATIO FORI
Table of contents
Annotation Estimate Publication content
References Comments
Share
QR
Metrics
ONCE MORE ON RESPONSA OF ROMAN JURISTS AND DISPUTATIO FORI
Annotation
PII
S0321-03910000392-7-1
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Alexandr Smyshlyev 
Edition
Issue 4
Pages
110-129
Abstract
The paper presents a critical analysis of L.L. Kofanov’s conception of Roman jurists of the Republican period. Kofanov proves that republican jurists were most active and influential public figures, always hanging around at people’s gatherings, authoritative orators, whose common opinion helped to maintain peace and accord in the civic community. The author of this paper considers such view to be one-sided and, as a whole, erroneous. In his opinion, this view finds no support in the sources and disagrees with the achievements of modern scholarship.
Keywords
Roman Republic, jurists, orators, people’s assembly, comitia, contiones, debates at the Forum, responsa prudentium
Date of publication
01.10.2014
Number of purchasers
1
Views
514
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite   Download pdf

References



Additional sources and materials


 Garsia Garrido M.Kh. 2005: Rimskoe chastnoe pravo: kazusy, iski, instituty / Per. s isp.; L.L. Kofanov (otv. red.). M.
 Digesty Yustiniana 1984: Izbrannye fragmenty v perevode i s primechaniyami I.S. Pereterskogo. M.
 Digesty Yustiniana 2002: Per. s latin.; L.L. Kofanov (otv. red.). T. I. M.
 Dozhdev D.V. 1996: Rimskoe chastnoe pravo. Uchebnik dlya vuzov / Pod red. V.S. Nersesyantsa. M.
 Dydynskij F. 1997: Latinsko-russkij slovar' k istochnikam rimskogo prava / Po izdaniyu 1896 goda. M.
 Kofanov L.L. 2006: Lex i ius: vozniknovenie i razvitie rimskogo prava v VIII-III vv. do n.eh. M.
 Kofanov L.L. 2014: Rol' responsa rimskikh yuristov v disputatio forensis v rimskoj grazhdanskoj obschine V-I vv. do n.eh. // VDI. 4, 87-110.
 Moro F. 2004: Sublata priore lege. Otvod rogationes kak sposob vneseniya popravok k zakonodatel'nym proektam v kontse Respubliki // VDI. 4, 154-166.
 Smyshlyaev A.L. 2003: Narod, vlast', zakon v pozdnerespublikanskom Rime (po povodu kontseptsii F. Millara) // VDI. 3, 46-60.
 Smyshlyaev A.L., Odegova E.A. 2006: Problema «rimskoj demokratii» v sovremennoj zarubezhnoj istoriografii // Akademklub. Istoricheskie nauki. Vyp. 2. Antichnaya istoriya i klassicheskaya arkheologiya / V.V. Dement'eva (otv. red.). M., 64-78.
 Tsitseron 1966: Dialogi. O gosudarstve. O zakonakh / Izd. podgotovili I.N. Veselovskij, V.O. Gorenshtejn i S.L. Utchenko. M.
 Bauman R.A. 1983: Lawyers in Roman republican politics. A study of the Roman jurists in their political setting, 316-82 BC. Munchen.
 Bonfante P. 1925: La progressiva diversificazione del diritto pubblico e privato / Bonfante P. Scritti giuridici vari. Vol. IV. Studi generali. Roma, 28-43.
 Cancelli F 2010: La codificazione dell’Edictum praetoris: dogma romanistico. Milano.
 Corbino A. 2012: Diritto privato romano. Contesti, fondamenti, discipline. 2 ed. Padova.
 Crook J.A. 1984: Law and Life of Rome, 90 B.C. - A.D. 212. N.Y.
 Helssig R. 1891: Die romische Rechtswissenschaft im Zeitalter des Augustus // Augustus und seine Zeit / V. Gardthausen (ed.). Lpz, I. 1, 901-915.
 Lubtow U. von 1948: De iustitia et iure // ZSS. 66, 458-565.
 Mommsen Th. 1859: Die romische Chronologie bis auf Caesar. B.
 Petrucci A. 2012: Corso di diritto pubblico romano. Torino.
 Plisecka A. 2009: The Roman Jurists' Law during the passage from the Republic to the Empire // Jahrbuch Junge Rechtsgeschichte. 4, 372-392.
 Rotondi G. 1912: Leges publicae populi Romani. Milano.
 Ruggiero A. 1968: Responsa prudentium // Novissimo Digesto Italiano. Vol. XV. Torino, 613-616.
 Santalucia B. 1998: Diritto e processo penale nell’antica Roma. Milano.
 Schiavone A. 1987: Giuristi e nobili nella Roma repubblicana. Il secolo della revoluzione scientifica nel pensiero giuridico antico. Roma-Bari.
 Schulz F. 1946: History of Roman legal science. Oxf.
 Schulz F. 1968: Storia della giurisprudenza romana. Firenze.
 Tuori K. 2004: The ius respondendi and the Freedom of Roman Jurisprudence // RIDA. 51, 295-337.
 Zulueta F. de 1953: The Institutes of Gaius. Part II. Commentary. Oxf.
 Watson A. 1974: Law making in the Later Roman republic. Oxf.
 Wesener G. 1962: Promulgatio // RE. Suppl. 9, 1239-1241.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate